Grading Penguins GM Jim Rutherford; The First-Half Report Card

The Pittsburgh Penguins approaching a lapse to being a Stanley Cup contender. Last summer, Penguins GM Jim Rutherford deserted overtures of change or renovate and stood pat with his core organisation of players and direction.

The Penguins had a longer summer to rest, recuperate and transparent a mental palette. After 3 prolonged years that enclosed a romantic tumult and organizational shake of a switch from Mike Johnston to Mike Sullivan, a 2016 Stanley Cup march, a really brief summer for several of a Penguins cornerstone pieces in a 2016 World Cup of Hockey, and a 2017 Stanley Cup march, a Penguins had a possibility to breathe in credentials for a 2018-19 season.

On paper, Rutherford’s offseason sum with rest should have launched a inspired and indignant team.

At a start, a Penguins had a best core contingent in a joining with Sidney Crosby, Evgeni Malkin and Derick Brassard. Evgeni Malkin had challenged for a Art Ross and Hart Trophies in a deteriorate before and a Penguins approaching Jake Guentzel to mature from his sophomore slump. Kris Letang was healthy and Rutherford usually nibbled during a edges of his roster.

Put a pin in a Brassard problem. It was a Penguins initial undoing.

The Penguins combined abyss on Jun 26 and dealt Conor Sheary and Matt Hunwick to Buffalo for breeze picks, that is where we will start a Penguins offseason. Then, final July, Rutherford sealed giveaway agents Jack Johnson, Derek Grant and Matt Cullen for a NHL roster, and sealed Zach Trotman, Teddy Blueger, and Jimmy Hayes for NHL depth.

Rutherford inked defenseman Jamie Oleksiak to a three-year prolongation during a really affordable $2.1 million annual top hit. The Penguins GM also handed two-year contracts to wingers Daniel Sprong and Dominik Simon, and a one-year understanding to Riley Sheahan.

The Penguins approaching their core to be prepared and a abyss including a bolt of centers to produce conduct manager Mike Sullivan several options.

On paper, Rutherford had finished a plain pursuit even if a offseason didn’t embody a splashy add. The Penguins offseason was tangible by a gripping their splashy option: Phil Kessel.

Rutherford certified he famous really fast a Penguins were a incongruous group and a core was stale. He dealt renouned and rapid Carl Hagelin for Tanner Pearson, afterwards finally finished a Daniel Sprong conditions by traffic him for Marcus Pettersson.

(Rutherford after spun Pearson for defenseman Erik Gudbranson, afterwards Brassard and Sheahan for Nick Bjugstad and Jared McCann. A understanding that looks like an comprehensive take though that will be in tomorrow’s final grade).

Rutherford also rewarded Jake Guentzel with a new five-year agreement with a $6 million AAV in Dec and backup goalie Casey DeSmith warranted an affordable 3 year deal.

Rutherford First-Half Grade: D+

The losses:

Derick Brassard. The Penguins third line core told a Penguins he didn’t like or wish to be a third line core final May, nonetheless they kept him in hopes it would work. It didn’t.

Keeping Brassard was a Penguins good first-half undoing. If Rutherford didn’t feel his patrol became a team, demeanour no serve than a Brassard situation. It wrecked a lineup and kept a Penguins from anticipating a rhythm.

Derek Grant never fit with a group and upheld back-and-forth by waivers. Grant also blocked Teddy Blueger from a NHL (but that might have been a blessing as Blueger combined a scoring hold in WBS).

The Penguins didn’t need to go by a Daniel Sprong situation, either. No maestro indeed rolled his eyes when asked about Sprong or personification with Sprong, though a integrate came close. Cullen did his best to assistance a immature actor though for several reasons mostly centered on Sprong, it was never going to work.

The GM believed in Daniel Sprong that combined an ungainly situation. Sullivan was saddled with a actor who frequency showed NHL chops, positively not a enterprise to play reduce line duty. And Sprong was forced to infer himself NHL prepared before being postulated scoring line opportunities.

The Sprong disturbance primarily blocked Zach Aston-Reese from a NHL, and as it incited out Garrett Wilson, too. However, by going by a process, Pettersson became available. So, alls good that ends well.

The Hagelin trade was iffy during a time. It positively didn’t produce equal formula with Tanner Pearson, who was a bust. Pearson had usually 14 points (9g, 5a) in 44 games and didn’t produce a puck retrieval or chastisement murdering bravery of Hagelin.

The Hagelin for Pearson trade would itself acquire a D or F.

The Wins:

Rutherford’s ability to shun from Matt Hunwick and Conor Sheary was a apt move. Sheary would not have fit good with a Penguins pull to hang onto pucks.

Cullen generally was extravagantly renouned with a immature players who he shepherded this season, including Aston-Reese and Garrett Wilson. This contributor watched Bryan Rust also find out a correct virtuoso recommendation of Cullen on several occasions. Cullen was a Penguins shutdown center, too. The Penguins eventually found a fourth line means of descent grant with Sheahan–Cullen–Aston-Reese.

The Marcus Petterson trade was an comprehensive take for a Penguins, too.

Simon constructed 28 points (8g, 20) that annoy fans though a playmaking winger combined a lot of offense for a Penguins for usually $750,000.

The Guentzel prolongation also looks like a bargain, too.

The middle: 

The prolongation to Jamie Oleksiak looked like a good understanding though wasn’t. The new agreement to Rust looked a bit high though will be a satisfactory cost for a actor means to measure 20 goals per year while shuffling by a lineup.

Jack Johnson is a C+ defender creation a C+ salary. At this point, amicable media is so thick with annoy that this author doesn’t design any object to dig it, though Johnson gave a Penguins a few much-needed layers including trustworthiness and physicality in a defensive zone. Johnson also committed usually 32 turnovers that places him good next a rest of a Penguins defense. Johnson’s indicate sum and offense will need to improve.

After a merger of Pettersson, Johnson’s low analytics severely improved, too. Using a baseline metric of scoring chances, Johnson was about even. Interestingly, Johnson increasing Justin Schultz’ numbers.

(Funny story, during a celebration Saturday, a reader approached me and whispered, “I indeed like Jack Johnson though you’re not authorised to contend that. We both laughed though a Twitter host and blogosphere positively gets aggressive. And a actor has noticed).

Tomorrow–The Final Grade.

Posted in
Tagged . Bookmark the permalink.
short link